Rated 1 out of
5
by
9853 from
Disappointing
I was happy to find a grey eyeliner. The package description sounded great. Unfortunately the product wasn't. It kept breaking off in little pieces. The gel was very un-gel-like. very hard and difficult to apply. The pieces broke off as I used it but also just as I was dialing it up. I suspect it was broken in the pencil already. I literally could point the pencil down and a piece would fall off.
Date published: 2016-10-21
Rated 5 out of
5
by
EricaC from
BEST EYELINER>>>EVER!
I have never written a review for an eyeliner before, but I am moved to write a review for this liner, as it simply is the best!! I absolutely love it! I always have the hardest time putting on eyeliner correctly. I watch youtube channels, ask makeup artist for tips and still struggled! Until I bought this liner!! The super skinny tip makes applying eyeliner a cinch! I rave about this eyeliner all the time and convinced two of my friends to buy it too and they love it as well. Thank you for such an awesome product! #biggestfan!
Date published: 2017-01-07
Rated 5 out of
5
by
Nayy from
Love it
I love this eyeliner and I have a feeling that it will no longer be on the shelves. I can't find it in several stores. I don't know what I will use if Maybelline decides to discontinue this product. I searched for a long time to find an eyeliner the would not look so bold and thick when applied to the lower part of my eyes. This eyeliner goes on smooth and it alows me to make the line as thick as I like. This has been awesome but now I am afraid that I will not be able to find it. I will be driving around tomorrow to buy as many as I can find.
Date published: 2017-02-17
Rated 5 out of
5
by
purplemooglittergirl from
One of my favorites
I've been using this for several months now. Never had any issues that others have been complaining about. It is very soft and easy to apply, can blend if you wish. Will stay all day. Never had an issue with it breaking, but I never extend it more than a few clicks, maybe 5, past the tip. Love it for creating thin, delicate lines and lining my waterline. Only downside is it doesn't stay the best on my waterline, but overall a great liner.
Date published: 2016-11-24
Rated 2 out of
5
by
April ginger from
Great size, doesn't wear all day.
I have worn this three times now. And I'm surprised that nobody else is reviewing about this issue. But halfway through the day I won't notice that my eyeliner is actually crumbling and looking very dry and brittle on my eyelid. I do not over apply are you short strokes and just barely line my top eye. Like I said everything will time it has started to crumble halfway through the day obviously looking really bad. I have had to get out my brush and Gel pot liner and go over it. I never wear that much eyeliner so of course that is not how I like to do my make up .
Is anyone else experienced this kind of reaction with this make up ? For that reason I do not recommend this product .
Date published: 2017-06-04
Rated 5 out of
5
by
Fluffie427 from
Love this eyeliner
I always receive compliments on how thin my liner is, and I pass on the info of the product to everyone. However, I just returned from my local RiteAid and CVS stores empty-handed, cause they're out of stock. Had the same problem with the Line Stylist that was discontinued and which the Skinny replaced. Please tell me you're not going to stop making it. No other company makes a thin eyeliner. I need this!!!
Date published: 2017-03-03
Rated 5 out of
5
by
Jenn12387 from
Stays on All Day
I took a chance on this brown liner for simpler day wear and love it! Have it in all three colors now. It does occassionally break a little at the tip, but it's thin, you have to be gentle a bit. It goes on smooth and stays all day!! Love this product!
Date published: 2016-12-22
Rated 5 out of
5
by
RaeP from
Loving this Eyeliner!
Love the way it stays put on the waterline but smudges softly on my eyelid. Lasts all day without migrating and is super comfortable. Haven't had any problems with the product breaking. Went and bought a second color today.
Date published: 2016-02-21
